Full range ko partial: wanne ke gina tsoka? Taƙaitaccen binciken faɗin motsi
Shin motsa gaɓa gaba ɗaya (full range) ko wani ɓangare kawai (partial) yana canza girman tsoka da ƙarfi? Sakamakon nazarce-nazarce na tsari da meta-bincike guda biyu, cikin hotuna.
Full range ko partial: wanne ya fi?Daga nazari da meta-bincike na kwatanta faɗin motsi
Shin wannan ya shafe ka?
- Ba ka da tabbacin zurfin da ya kamata ka yi squat
- Motsinka yana zama marar zurfi yayin da kake ƙara nauyi
- Kana so ka san ko partial reps suna da amfani
Abin da wannan labari ya ƙunsa
- Bambancin full range, wato motsa gaɓa a faɗi mai girma, da partial, wato motsa wani ɓangare kawai
- Sakamakon partial a wurin da tsoka ta miƙu
- Abin da aka sani game da kowane sashin jiki (ƙasan jiki, saman jiki)
Taƙaitaccen bayani
Full range da partial
- A meta-bincike na 2023, full range (motsa gaɓa a faɗi mai girma) ya ɗan fi kaɗan gaba ɗaya, amma bambancin ƙarami ne sosai [2].
- Wani nazari na tsari na 2020 ya kammala cewa girman tsoka na ƙasan jiki ya fi girma da full range [1].
- Partial da aka yi a wurin da tsoka ta miƙu na iya zama ma ya fi a girman tsoka, amma har yanzu ba tabbas [2].
Wane bincike ne wannan
Wannan labari yana kawo bincike biyu da suka taƙaita binciken da suka kwatanta faɗin motsi (nisan da gaɓa ke motsawa).
- Nazari na tsari na 2020 [1]: ya haɗa bincike 6 da mutane 135 (maza 127, mata 8). Bincike huɗu na ƙasan jiki ne, biyu na saman jiki [1].
- Nazari na tsari da meta-bincike na 2023 [2]: ya tara binciken da suka kwatanta full range da partial kuma ya yi nazarin sakamako da dama tare, har da ƙarfi da girman tsoka [2].
Full range da partial
- Full range: amfani da babban ɓangare na faɗin da gaɓa za ta iya motsawa a motsa jiki.
- Partial: motsawa a wani ɓangare kawai. Bisa ga wane ɓangare ne, ana iya raba shi zuwa wurin da tsoka ta miƙu (ɓangaren miƙuwa) da wurin da ta taƙu.
Abin da aka gano
2023: full range ya ɗan fi kaɗan gaba ɗaya
Idan aka haɗa dukkan sakamako, full range ya ɗan fi kaɗan (standardized mean difference 0.12) [2]. Amma marubutan sun kira wannan bambanci "maras muhimmanci (trivial)", kuma tazarar tabbaci 95% (−0.02 zuwa 0.26) ta ratsa 0 [2]. Idan aka duba kowane sakamako, bambance-bambancen sun kasance 0.05 zuwa 0.2, duk ƙanana ne sosai zuwa ƙanana masu karkata zuwa full range [2].
Bambancin full range da partial (gaba ɗaya, 2023)
- 0Babu bambanci
- 0.12Kiyasi (zuwa full range)
Partial a wurin miƙuwa
A girman tsoka, kwatanta partial a wurin miƙuwa da full range ya ba da kiyasin cewa partial na iya fi (standardized mean difference −0.28) [2]. Amma tazarar tabbaci 95% ta −0.81 zuwa 0.16 tana da faɗi kuma ta ratsa 0, don haka ba za a iya faɗin wani abu a bayyane ba [2].
2020: full range ga ƙasan jiki, saman jiki ba a sani ba tukuna
Nazarin 2020 ya kammala cewa girman tsoka na ƙasan jiki ya fi girma da full range [1]. Game da saman jiki, bincike kaɗan ne kuma sakamakonsu ya saɓa, don haka ba a iya cimma ƙarshe a bayyane na aiki ba [1]. Babu binciken da ya duba tsokokin kututture [1].
Taƙaitawa bisa sashin jiki (nazarin 2020)
| Sashin jiki | Adadin bincike | Sakamako |
|---|---|---|
| Ƙasan jiki | 4 | Girman tsoka ya fi girma da full range |
| Saman jiki | 2 | Bincike kaɗan, sakamako masu saɓani |
| Kututture | 0 | Babu bincike |
Yadda za a fahimce shi
- Idan kana shakka, motsawa a faɗi mai girma shi ne tushe. Marubutan 2023 sun bayyana cewa full range (ko motsin da ke amfani da wurin miƙuwa) na iya inganta sakamako da yawa [2].
- Partial ma yana da amfaninsa. Sun bayyana cewa idan kana da damuwa game da gaɓoɓi ko akwai iyakar kayan aiki, partial zai iya zama isasshen madadin [2].
- Partial a wurin miƙuwa har yanzu ba tabbas. Yana a matakin "na iya fi a girman tsoka", tare da kiyasi mai faɗi [2].
- Bincike kaɗan ne. Nazarin 2020 ya ƙunshi bincike 6, kuma kusan dukkan mahalarta maza ne [1].
Tambayoyin da ake yawan yi
Shin partial reps za su iya gina tsoka?
Meta-binciken 2023 ya gano bambancin da full range ba shi da muhimmanci, kuma ya kammala cewa partial zai iya zama isasshen madadin [2]. Amma gaba ɗaya, full range ya ɗan fi kaɗan [2].
Shin in yi squat mai zurfi?
A nazarin 2020, sakamakon shi ne girman tsoka na ƙasan jiki ya fi girma da full range [1]. Taƙaitattun bayanan binciken da ke wannan labari ba za su iya faɗin takamaiman zurfi ba.
Shin gaskiya ne partial na ɓangaren miƙuwa ya fi?
Kiyasin shi ne partial a wurin miƙuwa na iya fi full range a girman tsoka [2]. Amma tazarar tana da faɗi, don haka ba za mu iya cewa akwai bambanci ba [2].
Ka tabbatar a Torevo
Idan ka rubuta nauyi da maimaitawa, za ka ga yadda kiyasin 1RM ɗinka yake tafiya a kowane motsa jiki. Canza faɗin motsi yana sa rubuce-rubucen motsa jiki ɗaya su yi wuyar kwatantawa, don haka barin bayani yana sauƙaƙa dubawa daga baya.
Manazarta
- Schoenfeld BJ, Grgic J (2020). Effects of range of motion on muscle development during resistance training interventions: A systematic review. SAGE Open Medicine. doi:10.1177/2050312120901559
- Wolf M, Androulakis-Korakakis P, Fisher J, Schoenfeld B, Steele J (2023). Partial Vs Full Range of Motion Resistance Training: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. International Journal of Strength and Conditioning. doi:10.47206/ijsc.v3i1.182
Wannan labarin taƙaitaccen bincike ne, ba shawarar likita ba. Idan kana da wata cuta ko rauni, ka yi magana da likita kafin ka fara motsa jiki.