Can light weights build muscle? A meta-analysis comparing low and high loads
A meta-analysis of 21 studies comparing muscle growth and strength gains with light loads (60% of 1RM or less) and heavier loads, explained with figures.
Can light weights build muscle?From a meta-analysis of 21 studies comparing ≤60% and >60% of 1RM
Is this you?
- Heavy weights worry you or bother your joints
- You want to know whether light weights and more reps build muscle
- You are not sure how heavy to go for strength
What this article covers
- Whether light and heavy loads build muscle differently
- Which gave larger 1RM (maximal strength) gains
- How to choose a load for your goal
Summary
Taken to failure, which grew more?
- When sets were taken to failure, muscles grew about the same with light and heavy loads [1].
- 1RM increased more with heavy loads [1].
- The authors conclude that maximal strength calls for heavy loads, while for muscle growth a wide range of loads can be used [1].
The research
This is a systematic review and meta-analysis published in 2017 [1]. It defines 60% of 1RM or less as "low load" and anything heavier than 60% as "high load", and gathers studies that compared the two. It covers 21 studies [1].
What the studies had in common
To read these results, it matters which studies were included [1].
- Experiments that used both low-load and high-load training
- Every set was taken to the point where no more reps could be done (muscular failure)
- Muscle size or strength was measured (dynamic strength, isometric strength where the joint does not move, and so on)
- Training lasted at least 6 weeks
- Participants had no illness or injury that would interfere with training
What 60% of 1RM means
1RM is the most weight you can lift once with good form. For someone whose 1RM is 100 kg, 60% is 60 kg.
What they found
- Muscle growth: there was no large difference in muscle growth between low and high loads [1].
- 1RM strength: high loads produced clearly larger gains [1].
- Isometric strength (force produced without moving the joint): no difference between the two conditions [1].
How to read it
- To build muscle with light weights, go close to failure. These results come from studies where every set was taken to failure [1]. This study cannot say what happens with light weights when you stop with plenty of reps left.
- To raise your 1RM, you also need heavy weights. Getting used to lifting the heavy weight itself is thought to drive 1RM gains.
- You can choose by situation. On days when a joint feels off, or where equipment is limited, lighter weights for more reps are an option.
- Going to failure is demanding. With light weights, reaching failure takes many reps, and some people find it hard. Do it with exercises and in settings where you can stop before your form breaks down.
Frequently asked questions
Can I build muscle at home with only light dumbbells?
In this study, with every set taken to failure, light loads of 60% of 1RM or less grew muscle about as much as heavy loads [1]. This study cannot say what happens if you stop with reps left.
What if I want to raise my bench press?
1RM increased more in groups that trained with heavy loads [1]. If you want to lift more, it seems worthwhile to include heavy training too.
How many reps makes a weight "light"?
The study's cut-off is not a number of reps but a share of 1RM (60% or less) [1]. At the same share, how many reps you can do varies by person and exercise.
Check it in Torevo
If you log weights and reps, you can see each exercise's estimated 1RM over time. When you change the range of weights you use, compare how your estimated 1RM and your body change.
References
- Schoenfeld BJ, Grgic J, Ogborn D, Krieger JW (2017). Strength and Hypertrophy Adaptations Between Low- vs. High-Load Resistance Training: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. doi:10.1519/JSC.0000000000002200 · PubMed 28834797
This article summarizes research and is not medical advice. If you have a medical condition or an injury, talk to a doctor before you start training.